Skip to the content
Refined on a Budget

10 guides across 5 departments, and 2 free tools.

Splurge vs Save Planner: Where to Spend and Where to Save When Renovating

  • Published

Where you spend matters more than how much. In the 2025 Cost vs. Value Report a midrange minor kitchen remodel recouped 113% of its cost, a midrange major remodel 51% and an upscale major remodel 36%. This planner applies those national shares to your budget and lists sourced splurge and save advice for each room, with the dates and sources shown.

Splurge vs save planner

Choose a room and a budget. The planner shows what share of the money the 2025 Cost vs. Value Report says came back at resale for each kind of project in that room, then lists the splurge and save advice we can source. Everything runs in your browser.

Defaults in use: the kitchen, and a budget of $10,000 (a round starting number, not a typical cost). The resale shares are national averages from the 2025 report, not local figures, and the bands (strong, partial, low) are our own labels: at or above 100%, 50 to under 100%, and under 50%.

Your room and budget

What you plan to spend on this project.

Your plan

How the splurge vs save planner works

The Cost vs. Value Report prices typical projects and estimates the resale value each adds, nationally. Dividing resale value by job cost gives the share recouped. The planner applies each project's share to your budget, so you can compare how much of the money tends to come back. Separately, it lists advice rules that quote their own source, such as NKBA guidance on cabinets, so that no rule is invented.

Share recouped and net cost
share recouped = resale value ÷ job cost × 100
recouped on your budget = budget × share recouped ÷ 100
net cost = budget − recouped on your budget
resale value, job cost
national averages for the project in the 2025 Cost vs. Value Report

Example: $10,000 in the kitchen

Worked example

Given: Budget $10,000; Kitchen projects from the 2025 report.

  1. Minor kitchen remodel, midrange: $32,141 ÷ $28,458 = 112.9% $10,000 × 112.9% = $11,294 back; net cost $-1,294
  2. Major kitchen remodel, midrange: $42,130 ÷ $82,793 = 50.9% $10,000 × 50.9% = $5,089 back; net cost $4,911
  3. Major kitchen remodel, upscale: $58,561 ÷ $164,104 = 35.7% $10,000 × 35.7% = $3,569 back; net cost $6,431

Answer: At national averages, the project type changes how much comes back far more than the budget does. Midrange work that keeps the cabinet boxes recouped the most.

The figures behind the planner

Remodeling Cost vs. Value Report 2025, national averages (job cost, resale value, share recouped)
ProjectJob costResale valueRecouped
Minor kitchen remodel, midrange (kitchen) $28,458$32,141113%
Major kitchen remodel, midrange (kitchen) $82,793$42,13051%
Major kitchen remodel, upscale (kitchen) $164,104$58,56136%
Bath remodel, midrange (bathroom) $26,138$20,91580%
Bath remodel, upscale (bathroom) $81,612$34,00042%
Entry door replacement (steel), midrange (entry and garage) $2,435$5,270216%
Grand entrance (fiberglass), upscale (entry and garage) $11,754$9,95985%
Garage door replacement, midrange (entry and garage) $4,672$12,507268%
Siding replacement (fiber-cement), midrange (siding, windows and decks) $21,485$24,420114%
Siding replacement (vinyl), midrange (siding, windows and decks) $17,950$17,31396%
Window replacement (vinyl), midrange (siding, windows and decks) $22,073$16,65775%
Window replacement (wood), upscale (siding, windows and decks) $26,781$18,76470%
Deck addition (wood), midrange (siding, windows and decks) $18,263$17,32395%
Deck addition (composite), upscale (siding, windows and decks) $25,096$22,19988%

Source: Cost vs. Value 2025 (published June 20, 2025), national averages, accessed 2026-11-14. Percentages are resale value divided by job cost.

Assumptions and limits

  • The shares are national averages for specific project definitions in the report, such as a 200 square foot kitchen with 30 linear feet of cabinets. Your project and market differ, and resale value depends on the buyer.
  • The report measures resale value, not enjoyment. If you will stay for years, a high-end finish you love can be worth more to you than its recoup share says.
  • NKBA's cabinet guidance is dated 2012. The principles are cost structure, not prices; for current prices use the cabinet refacing cost estimator.
  • Splurge and save labels follow the source for each rule. The strong, partial and low bands are our own thresholds.
  • This is planning information, not financial or appraisal advice. For a sale, ask a local agent what buyers in your area value.

Frequently asked questions

Where should I splurge in a kitchen?

On the parts you touch every day and cannot see. NKBA says the best cabinet hinges keep doors aligned and adjust in every direction, and that homeowners are tempted to scrimp on them because they are hidden. Spend on hinges and drawer glides, and save on door detailing, since NKBA says finish and front detailing can determine as much as three-quarters of a cabinet's cost.

What should I save on?

Things where the extra money buys looks rather than function or resale. In the 2025 Cost vs. Value report, upscale versions recouped less of their cost than midrange ones: a kitchen at about 36% versus about 51%, a bathroom at about 42% versus about 80%. Reusing cabinet boxes and refacing, which NKBA puts at about half the cost of comparable new cabinets, is another save if the layout works.

How should I allocate a $10,000 budget?

Pick the project first, because each recoups a different share. At the national averages in the 2025 report, $10,000 spent like a midrange minor kitchen remodel would bring back about $11,294, spent like a midrange major remodel about $5,089. These are national averages for whole projects, not a forecast for yours.

Do splurges add resale value?

Some do and many do not. In the 2025 report, a steel entry door recouped about 216% of its cost and a garage door about 268%, while an upscale grand entrance recouped about 85% and an upscale major kitchen about 36%. Resale value is also local and depends on the buyer, so use the shares as a guide to which spends tend to return more, not as a promise.

Is hardware or cabinets the better place to spend?

They are different spends. NKBA says custom cabinetry can consume 50 to 60 percent of a kitchen budget and suggests mostly stock cabinets with some custom pieces. Knobs and pulls are a cheap way to refresh a look, particularly if you are staying only a few years, while hinges are worth paying for. So economise on the cabinet type, then spend on what moves.

Source notes

  1. Remodeling Cost vs. Value Report 2025, national averages (Journal of Light Construction) (jlconline.com) Published June 20, 2025. Accessed 2026-11-14. The 2026 edition was not yet published.
  2. NKBA: Kitchen Cabinet Cost Considerations (kb.nkba.org) Dated 2012-10-25. Accessed 2026-11-14.
  3. NKBA: Kitchen Cabinets Open Up New Possibilities (kb.nkba.org) Dated 2012-10-24. Accessed 2026-11-14.

Related guides